When families go through separation or divorce, determining parenting arrangements can be one of the most difficult decisions, especially when children have their own opinions about where they want to live.
As children get older, their preferences may grow stronger, and parents often wonder how much influence those opinions should have when deciding parenting time.
In Alberta, children can express their views, but that does not necessarily mean they have the final say.
Understanding how Alberta courts approach parenting separation disputes can help parents better understand their legal responsibilities, the role of their child’s preferences, and how parenting decisions are made.
How Alberta Courts Make Parenting Decisions
When parents cannot agree on parenting arrangements, the court’s primary consideration is the child’s best interests.
This involves looking at several factors, including the child’s physical, emotional, and psychological needs, their relationships with each parent, the stability of their living arrangements, and any concerns involving family violence or safety.
The child’s views may also be considered, but they are only one part of the overall decision.
Rather than focusing on what either parent wants, the court must determine which arrangements best support the child’s needs and well-being.
Does a Child Get to Choose Which Parent They Live With?
One of the most common misconceptions about parenting disputes is that children automatically get to choose where they live once they reach a certain age.
In Alberta, there is no set age at which a child can decide which parent they live with.
Instead, courts consider the child’s wishes alongside other relevant factors, including their age, maturity, and ability to understand the situation.
For example, an older teenager’s preferences may carry more weight than a younger child’s. However, even when a child expresses a strong preference, the court must still consider what is in their best interests.
The Difference Between a Child Having a Voice and Having a Choice
An important distinction in family law is the difference between allowing children to express their opinions and giving them responsibility for making parenting decisions.
Having a voice means a child’s thoughts, feelings, and preferences can be heard and considered. Having a choice means allowing the child to make the final decision about their parenting arrangements.
These are not the same thing.
For example, a child may prefer spending weekdays with one parent because their school and friends are nearby. The court can consider that preference without allowing it to determine the entire parenting schedule.
This approach lets children participate in decisions that affect their lives without placing the responsibility for those decisions on them.
How Age and Maturity Affect a Child’s Views
As children get older, their opinions may carry greater weight, particularly when they can clearly explain their preferences and demonstrate an understanding of their circumstances.
In Raugust v Raugust, 2018 ABCA 30, the Alberta Court of Appeal refused to stay a lower court order that allowed a 14-year-old girl to decide how often she would spend parenting time with her father.
The case demonstrates how a teenager’s age, maturity, and independence can influence parenting arrangements.
However, this does not establish a specific age at which children can make their own decisions. Each case must still be considered individually.
How Courts Hear the Views of Children
Children do not necessarily have to appear in court for their opinions to be considered.
Depending on the circumstances, their views may be communicated through a lawyer representing the child, a qualified professional, or a formal assessment.
The court may also consider how those opinions developed, particularly when there are concerns that a child has been influenced by conflict between their parents.
The purpose is to understand the child’s perspective while ensuring they are not placed in the middle of the legal dispute.
Voice of the Child Reports and Parenting Assessments
In more complicated parenting disputes, additional information may be needed to help the court understand the child’s circumstances.
A Voice of the Child report gives children an opportunity to share their thoughts and preferences with a qualified professional, who then presents those views to the court. A parenting assessment takes a broader look at the family’s circumstances, including relationships, parenting abilities, and the child’s needs.
These reports can be particularly useful when parents disagree about their child’s preferences or when concerns arise about the child’s well-being.
However, not every parenting dispute requires a formal assessment, and the appropriate approach depends on the circumstances.
The Risk of Putting Children in the Middle of Parental Conflict
One of the biggest concerns in parenting disputes is the pressure children may experience when their parents disagree.
Children may feel responsible for choosing sides, worry about disappointing a parent, or believe they need to resolve disagreements between adults.
Even asking a child which parent they would prefer to live with can create unnecessary stress.
Parents should avoid involving children in arguments, speaking negatively about the other parent, or asking children to make decisions that should remain with the adults.
Keeping children out of parental conflict can help protect their emotional well-being during separation.
Parenting Disputes in High-Conflict Separations
Some separations involve ongoing disagreements that make parenting arrangements particularly difficult to manage.
Parents may struggle to communicate, disagree over parenting schedules, or raise concerns about the other parent’s influence on their child’s opinions.
When disagreements continue, the court may need to look more closely at how the conflict is affecting the child and what parenting arrangements would be appropriate.
In some circumstances, parallel parenting may be appropriate. This approach limits direct communication between parents while establishing clearer responsibilities for each household.
However, it is not suitable for every family, particularly when safety concerns or family violence are involved.
Parenting After Separation and High-Conflict Parenting Resources
Alberta provides several resources to help parents understand their responsibilities and manage disagreements following separation.
The Parenting After Separation (PAS) course provides information about parenting arrangements, communication, and the effects of separation on children.
The Parenting After Separation for Families in High Conflict (PASHC) program addresses the challenges associated with ongoing parental conflict and ways to reduce its impact on children.
Mincher Koeman has previously been involved in teaching the Parenting After Separation for Families in High Conflict course, which helps parents understand how ongoing disagreements can affect their children and how to better manage conflict following separation.
The Government of Alberta also offers support for resolving parenting disputes, including Caseflow Conferences that may help families work toward agreements outside of court.
When to Get Legal Help With a Parenting Dispute
Parenting separation disputes can become particularly complicated when children express strong preferences, parents disagree about parenting time, or concerns arise about a child’s well-being.
Obtaining legal advice early can help parents understand their rights, responsibilities, and options for resolving disagreements.
At Mincher Koeman, we understand that parenting disputes involve more than legal questions. They involve family relationships, children’s needs, and decisions that can have a lasting impact on everyone involved.
Our team of family lawyers assists clients in Calgary, Canmore, and surrounding communities with parenting time, decision-making responsibilities, and high-conflict family matters. We take a team-based approach to helping families understand their options and work toward practical solutions.
If you are dealing with parenting separation disputes, contact Mincher Koeman to book an appointment to review your case. Our team can help you understand your legal options and determine the next steps for your family.





